Nambi Narayanan on ISRO’s Origin, battling fake cases & future of India’s space mission

Nambi Narayanan, an Indian aerospace scientist, led the cryogenic engine project at ISRO. He received the Padma Bhushan for his remarkable contributions to space technology.

Nambi Narayanan on ISRO’s Origin, battling fake cases & future of India’s space mission

TLDR: The key idea of the video is that Nambi Narayanan, a rocket scientist, discusses his personal experiences, challenges, and achievements in the Indian space program, while emphasizing the importance of justice, collaboration, and perseverance in the pursuit of scientific advancements.

00:00 🚀 Rocket scientist Nambi Narayanan discusses his personal experiences with false cases, media manipulation, and foreign sabotage, as well as his belief in extraterrestrial life and his bond with Vikram Sarai, while also highlighting ISRO’s humble origins and his pursuit of a higher degree in rocketry.

1.1 Vikram Lander was put into sleep mode due to a lack of funds, and the speaker discusses his personal experiences with false cases, media manipulation, and foreign sabotage.

1.2 Rocket scientist Nambi Narayanan, who worked with ISRO, discusses his belief in the existence of extraterrestrial life and his experience being falsely accused of selling secrets to Pakistan.

1.3 Nambi Narayanan recalls his first meeting with Vikram Sarai, where he was designing an explosive bolt and Vikram introduced himself as they both discussed their work.

1.4 The speaker recalls their first meeting with an important person, who they later learned was Vikram Sarai, and how their bond started from there.

1.5 ISRO’s origin was humble with only three buildings and limited resources, but it eventually grew into various centers and Nambi Narayanan’s conversation with Vikram Sarabhai led to his interest in studying liquid propulsion.

1.6 The speaker wanted to pursue a higher degree in rocketry but faced personal problems and financial constraints, eventually finding a program in Princeton that offered admission.

11:41 🚀 Retired scientist Nambi Narayanan discusses his journey, interactions with mentors, development of composite structures in ISRO, retirement, and confidence in the success of India’s recent space mission, Chandrayaan-2, while addressing comments about software errors.

2.1 Nambi Narayanan discusses his journey from receiving a NASA Fellowship to being offered a job in the aerospace industry in the USA, despite being from an underdeveloped country, and his interactions with Professor Groko.

2.2 Nambi Narayanan shares anecdotes about his interactions with his mentor and former President of India, APJ Abdul Kalam, including a humorous incident about alcohol and their shared passion for music and engineering.

2.3 Nambi Narayanan discusses the development of composite structures in ISRO, including the first composite nose cone, and reflects on his retirement and watching the Chandrayaan 3 mission on television.

2.4 The Vikram Lander and Pragyan Rover are currently in sleep mode to conserve power and protect them from extreme temperature conditions, and it is uncertain whether they will wake up or be considered dead.

2.5 Retired scientist Nambi Narayanan expressed confidence in the success of India’s recent space mission, Chandrayaan-2, based on his knowledge and discussions, and highlighted the excitement and silent prayers experienced by scientists during critical phases.

2.6 There were two comments regarding the error in the software of the computer program, one being the contradicting commands and the other being the stability of the system.

30:34 🚀 ISRO faced weight restrictions but utilized the Orbiter’s advantage for stability, the speaker discusses their involvement in naming the Vikas engine and their satisfaction with its performance, funding for space missions was limited in the past due to government perception of failures, the speaker faced skepticism and challenges in demonstrating their technology, the chairman of ISRO plays a crucial role in India’s space research, and the speaker emphasizes the importance of being a good person and overcoming tough times.

3.1 Due to weight restrictions, ISRO had to work with limited thrusters and reduced safety margins, but they were able to utilize the weight advantage of a still-functioning Orbiter to maintain stability.

3.2 The speaker discusses their involvement in naming the Vikas engine and their satisfaction with its successful performance, as well as their continued pride in its ongoing use.

3.3 Funding for space missions in the past was limited, but now there is more availability, and the lack of funds in the earlier days was due to the government’s perception of failures and delays in the SLV 3 project.

3.4 The speaker discusses his efforts to demonstrate his technology, including making a model of the vas engine and testing it in France, despite facing skepticism and challenges.

3.5 The chairman of ISRO plays a crucial role in determining the direction of India’s space research, with different personalities like Prof. Sadish Daan, Sarai, and Janardan having their own unique qualities and visions, but facing challenges such as lack of funding and misunderstandings.

3.6 Believing in fate and God’s guidance, the speaker shares their personal experience of overcoming tough times and emphasizes the importance of being a good person.

47:25 🚀 Despite funding shortages and political obstacles, ISRO’s space missions faced challenges due to a lack of understanding and geopolitical pressure, leading to false accusations against Nambi Narayanan, who continues to fight for justice with pending legal cases.

4.1 Shortage of funding and different priorities from the political establishment hindered the progress of ISRO’s space missions, despite the chairman’s efforts to fight for it.

4.2 Political bosses did not prioritize ISRO projects due to a lack of understanding and potential geopolitical pressure, leading to trials and tribulations for Nambi Narayanan, who was accused of being a traitor and selling secrets to Pakistan, but later discovered that foreign countries, including the USA, may have been interested in breaking the ISRO Russian contract due to the development of cryogenic missiles.

4.3 Russia was paid additional money for a broken cryogenic engine contract with India, and the Americans were against the transfer of technology, leading to sanctions on India, but it is understandable as nations act in their own interests.

4.4 Nambi Narayanan discusses his arrest and torture, stating that the aim was to remove him from the scene and that the case is still pending with 18 people possibly involved, but they couldn’t charge him with corruption or being a traitor.

4.5 Nambi Narayanan discusses his legal battle, the troubles faced by his family, and the strength he found in his conviction and belief in God to continue fighting against false accusations.

4.6 A person approached the speaker, offering help and running a program called “Canadi Mirror Mirror,” which gained credibility after the speaker’s first interview, leading to further collaboration.

01:03:51 🚀 Nambi Narayanan fought for 20 years to prove his innocence in a false case orchestrated by certain individuals within the government, with support from ISRO, and discusses the impact on his family and the importance of exposing wrongdoing.

5.1 Nambi Narayanan fought for 20 years to prove that the false case against him was orchestrated by certain individuals within the Kerala and central governments, while ISRO eventually supported him but took too long to do so.

5.2 The speaker discusses his work style and how he promotes and safeguards good workers, leading to the formation of a supportive community despite societal divisions.

5.3 The media, not being specialists in rocketry, believed and trusted the person briefing them, but later realized their mistake and slowly corrected it, so the media is not at fault for the misinformation spread about Nambi Narayanan.

5.4 Multiple individuals were involved in an international conspiracy against the speaker, with one person having a grudge and another being misled by their boss, leading to a media person throwing mud on a police officer, ultimately all stemming from one man who may have been the link between foreign agencies.

5.5 The speaker’s family had mixed reactions to the end of the case, with his son becoming pessimistic and his wife becoming speechless and psychologically affected, but ultimately recovering, while his family members supported him throughout the legal battles.

5.6 Nambi Narayanan discusses his determination to expose wrongdoing, fight for innocence, and clear his name, highlighting the importance of his case in legal journals.

01:15:23 🚀 India’s space mission has proven its ability to achieve minimal cost without sacrificing quality, and the speaker envisions the creation of an Asian space agency to collaborate with NASA and ESA for future missions, while also emphasizing the importance of privatization, cost-efficiency, and international cooperation in the aerospace industry.

6.1 The speaker believes that space exploration is not limited to one country and envisions the creation of an Asian space agency, involving countries like Vietnam, South Korea, Maldives, and Japan, to collaborate with NASA and ESA for future missions.

6.2 India’s space mission has proven its ability to achieve minimal cost without sacrificing quality, making it a valuable collaborator for Elon Musk’s goal of reaching outer space with minimal cost.

6.3 Privatization of space research is important for the growth of industries, economy, and international collaboration, and there should be a global understanding and cooperation among Asian countries in this field.

6.4 Developing cost-efficient systems and technologies in India and Asia requires having the necessary manpower and strategic planning, and it is important for the startup ecosystem to become more dynamic and internationally focused in order to make a significant impact in the aerospace industry.

6.5 Satellites and debris in space can be picked up and removed, but it may not be worth the effort unless it becomes a hindrance, and there is potential to repurpose recovered materials.

6.6 There is a belief that there could be life on other planets, and NASA is conducting research to understand and potentially discover this life.

01:25:06 🚀 Believing in God and having a scientific temper are not mutually exclusive, Nambi Narayanan faced extreme cruelty in jail but turned to faith, and encourages younger viewers to follow their passion for STEM and research.

7.1 Believing in God and having a scientific temper are not mutually exclusive, and scientists should have the freedom to believe or not believe in God without judgment or denial of their scientific abilities.

7.2 Facing extreme cruelty and torture in jail, Nambi Narayanan turned to faith and became more faithful, questioning the mistake he had made to go through such torture, and finding compensation in the fact that his name is now becoming popular.

7.3 Having a positive outlook is important for making things happen, and the speaker shares their personal experience of choosing a career in science and encourages younger viewers to follow their passion for STEM and research.

7.4 During World War II, the speaker developed a fascination with rockets, particularly the V2 rocket, and learned about Hitler’s involvement in its development.

7.5 Despite receiving admission to prestigious universities like Princeton and Caltech, the speaker chose to stay with his sick mother and eventually joined ISRO, believing it was a sign from God.

7.6 The speaker fought with their chief engineer, quit their job at a Sugar Factory, and then saw an advertisement for a rocket launching station with the last day to apply being over, but they convinced the director to let them apply anyway.

01:34:52 🚀 The political bickering over ISRO’s origin and contributions is seen as a result of political games, but the successful Chandrayaan mission brought unity and excitement among the people of India, while Nambi Narayanan discusses his career in space and his gratitude for the opportunity to be part of the podcast.

8.1 The political bickering over ISRO’s origin and contributions is seen by the scientific community as a result of political games, but the successful Chandrayaan mission brought unity and excitement among the people of India.

8.2 Scientists like Vikram Sarabhai and APJ Abdul Kalam have become well-known figures in India, and the speaker felt vindicated when the Supreme Court listened to his arguments and wrote a judgment in his favor, giving him hope for the country’s future.

8.3 He established a school at the request of his daughter and has found immense pleasure in working with children, while also discussing his strong and unwavering relationship with his wife despite facing various challenges.

8.4 The mental makeup of a scientist, whether an astrophysicist or a rocket scientist, involves being attached to their job and finding excitement in their own findings, even praying for successful tests, but feeling disappointed when things don’t go well.

8.5 Nambi Narayanan recalls an incident where he predicted a blast during a test stand experiment, resulting in his resignation from ISRO.

8.6 Nambi Narayanan discusses his decision to pursue a career in space despite facing obstacles and expresses gratitude for the opportunity to be part of the podcast.

Key Insights

⚖️ “Nambi Narayanan fought for 20 years to bring those responsible for his false case to justice.”

🚀 Nambi Narayanan’s life took a dramatic turn when he was falsely accused of selling secrets of Indian rocket technology to Pakistan, highlighting the challenges he faced and the controversy surrounding his case.

🕵️‍♂️ Nambi Narayanan’s investigation revealed that there were unknown individuals behind the false case, highlighting the challenges he faced in fighting against the government, media, and unidentified forces.

🤔 ISRO initially took time to support Nambi Narayanan, but eventually came forward to openly declare his innocence and support him.

🌍 The case against Nambi Narayanan involved an international conspiracy, with multiple individuals driven by personal motives, leading to a detrimental impact on his life and career.

😮 Shockingly, 42% of convicted individuals, including Nambi Narayanan, were innocent, emphasizing the need for reform and action to address wrongful convictions and police brutality.

🏛️ Nambi Narayanan felt vindicated when he had the opportunity to argue his own case in the Supreme Court and the judges understood his point, giving him hope for the country’s future.

Achievements and advancements in India’s space missions

😮 Nambi Narayanan reflects on the critical phase of the mission, describing the mix of excitement and silent prayers that scientists experience, emphasizing the intense focus and dedication required for success.

🌕 The success of Chandrayaan-2 was partly due to the decision to reuse the Orbiter from the previous mission, which provided a weight advantage and contributed to the mission’s stability.

😮 The Vikas engine exceeded its required burn time, reaching 1795 seconds, showcasing its success and demonstrating more than what was initially expected.

💪 ISRO’s proven track record in repeatability and consistency positions them as a key player in the future of India’s space missions.

🤝 Despite facing challenges and not having the required certificates, Nambi Narayanan’s determination and unique reasoning convinced the director of ISRO to allow him to apply for the job.

Importance of international collaboration and economic growth in space research

🚀 “I strongly believe that interplanetary travel or outer space is not going to be for one country, it’s for mankind.”

💰 Privatization of space research and industries can lead to economic growth and international collaboration, benefiting both the nation and mankind.

🌍 “They have to go International. It is not they should launch for ISRO alone…when you make money, the country makes money out of it.” - Nambi Narayanan highlights the need for India’s space startups to expand internationally and generate revenue for the country’s benefit.

Q&A

Q1: What were the main challenges faced during the Chandrayaan 2 mission and how did they impact the mission’s outcome?

A1: The Chandrayaan 2 mission faced several challenges, including software errors and stability issues. One key challenge was a contradiction in the software commands, which caused the onboard computer to crash. Additionally, the team faced a shortage of suitable thrusters, leading to compromises in weight and stability. Due to the limited options, they had to rely on a single thruster instead of two. These challenges had a significant impact on the mission, ultimately resulting in the failure of the Vikram Lander to achieve a successful landing on the lunar surface.

Q2: What role did Mr. Nambi Narayanan play in the development of the Vikas engine and his collaborations with notable figures in the field?

A2: Mr. Nambi Narayanan played a crucial role in the development of the Vikas engine, a powerful liquid-fueled rocket engine used in various Indian space missions. He worked closely with pioneers like Vikram Sarabhai and Dr. APJ Abdul Kalam. Mr. Narayanan’s contributions to the field of rocketry led to his recognition as a respected rocket scientist. He even had the opportunity to become a student of NASA through the recommendation of a respected professor. Mr. Narayanan’s interesting life and involvement in these collaborations have made him a prominent figure in the field of space exploration.

Q3: How did the media’s misinterpretations and misunderstandings impact Mr. Nambi Narayanan’s life and career?

A3: The media’s misinterpretations and misunderstandings had a significant impact on Mr. Nambi Narayanan’s life and career. He mentions that while some local media outlets offered support and assistance, mainstream media often wrote baseless and inaccurate stories. These false reports resulted in a highly publicized case against Mr. Narayanan, with accusations of espionage and selling secrets. The media-created controversy led to a decline in his reputation and subjected him to extreme cruelty and torture. However, after a long legal battle fighting for justice, the Supreme Court eventually declared the case false, proving Mr. Narayanan’s innocence.

Q4: How do collaborations with countries like Elon Musk’s SpaceX contribute to the growth of industries, economy, and humanity as a whole?

A4: Collaborations with countries and companies like Elon Musk’s SpaceX have the potential to contribute significantly to the growth of industries, the economy, and humanity as a whole. Elon Musk has been driven by the goal of reaching outer space at a minimal cost. Collaborating with organizations like ISRO can provide access to advanced technology, expertise, and resources needed to achieve this goal. By working together, countries and companies can pool their knowledge and resources, leading to advancements in space operations, technology, and exploration. This collaboration not only benefits the participating nations but also contributes to the growth of various industries, stimulates economic development, and promotes scientific advancements for the betterment of mankind.

Note - This content is generated by AI, we believe it is accurate, but we don’t claim any liability of inaccuracies in the AI generated content.

Watch the Episode